7 Best Routers for Comcast Xfinity in 2023 [Bought by 8/10 People]

To help you find a reliable router for your Xfinity connection, I tested 15 popular routers with different Xfinity internet plans for over 4 weeks. After testing each of them for several aspects such as internet speed, coverage, connectivity, security, and other features, I’ve picked the 7 best options of 2023.

Unlike modems that work with Xfinity, there’s no ISP compatibility factor for the routing part. However, despite that, finding the best device that matches your specific needs is not straightforward. You might end up purchasing one with mediocre specs or whose speeds don’t match the plan you’re subscribed to.

7 Best Comcast Xfinity Compatible Routers in 2023 [Expert Picks]

I tested 15 popular models with different Xfinity internet plans for over 4 weeks. Having switched to a suitable service plan with each device, I inspected them for several aspects, including practical speed, coverage, connectivity, security, and more. And I ended up qualifying top 7 WiFi routers that work with Xfinity.

Also, I have tried to include models that belong to multiple price brackets with varying features so that no one leaves empty-handed. You’ll find premium options at the top, followed by some mid-range picks, and budget options at the end.

1. Best for Xfinity Gigabit: TP-Link Archer AX90

Owing to WiFi 6, tri-band support, Wireless Speed upto 6600 Mbps (4804 Mbps + 1200 Mbps @ 5GHz + 574 Mbps @ 2GHz) and coverage upto 2,500 Sq Ft, the Archer AX90 is among the best-rated router to pair with Xfinity or any other ISPs.

TP-Link has done a great job with its networking devices, and its Archer AX73 gained some popularity by delivering reliable performance without asking much upfront. Now, the AX90 is a souped-up version of AX73 with an additional 5GHz band and an extra 2.5 Gbps LAN port. Its price isn’t hiked much compared to its predecessor, thereby holding its value.

Why is it suited for Xfinity?

Archer AX90 with 1.5GHz Quad-Core CPU supports tri-band Wi-Fi 6 up to 160MHz on its 5GHz bandwidth to deliver maximum speeds up to 4804 Mbps. In simple words, it is compatible with all service plans, so I chose it as the best router for the Xfinity gigabit plan.

Testing on my iPhone 13 at a short distance, the 5GHz band of AX90 can deliver speeds up to 950 Mbps on the Gigabit plan. While the 2.4GHz band had speeds clocked at 400 Mbps. Besides, its long-distance speed test yields better results, valuing 700 Mbps and 250 Mbps for 5GHz and 2.4GHz bands, respectively, thanks to its strong wireless coverage.

However, the additional 5GHz backhaul band expectedly offers faster and more consistent speeds than others. With such speeds, I could transfer 2.5GB of a folder containing songs, videos, and songs, which took no longer than a few seconds. I also streamed 4K movies and videos simultaneously without lags or latencies.

Note: Since, it’s can handle the fastest Xfinity Internet plan, you can use it with other Xfinity plans, i.e. Xfinity Extreme, Blaze, etc.

WiFi Coverage & Connections Capacity

With 8 external beamforming antennas, covering an area of up to 2,500 Sq Ft, and working on 10 devices at a time on this Xfinity-compatible WiFi router felt like a breeze. My family went on playing games on Xbox and PlayStation, streaming 4K videos, video conferencing, and browsing the web without any issues.

Ports & Connectivity

With an additional 2.5Gig WAN port, it already feels like an upgrade with which you can achieve multi-gigs of speeds. Besides, there’s Link Aggregation support on its four Gigabit LAN ports, so you can get 2X WiFi speeds on your router by combining two internet connections. This makes the device much more versatile than any other routers in the retail space.

Security Features

Archer AX90 boasts the latest WPA3 Wi-Fi security and VPN-passthrough right out of the box that keeps your database and user credentials encrypted. Besides, an Avira-powered TP-Link Homeshield antivirus feature keeps your network and devices protected from malware or viruses. But, you need to pay for it monthly once you’re done with its 1-month trial period.

Aside from that, controlling the online activities of your family is also much easier with the upgraded HomeShield security. You can control which websites your kids can access, schedule the online time, and pause the Wi-Fi anytime.

Conclusion

Overall, Archer AX90 is a highly recommended router for Xfinity with its stability and performance. WiFi 6 with tri-band support is helpful, especially if you have more devices to connect. Also, its network security is much more efficient and no-nonsense with the robust Homeshield Pro.

2. Best Gaming Router: ASUS RT-AX82U (Dual Band)

ASUS devices are quite popular among professional games owing to their Gaming support. But the RT-AX82U with the priority gaming port, dedicated mobile gaming mode and the RGB light is like a paradise to a gamer!

ASUS RT-AX82U is one of the most reliable gaming wireless routers that include a couple of gamers-friendly features. Unlike other Xfinity-compatible routers, you get a dedicated mobile gaming mode, priority gaming port, AURA RGB light, and more to complement your gaming setup.

So, if you’re into gaming or live streaming, get yourself a bigger upgrade over the old RT-AX86U with one additional antenna, greater speed, and security.

Why is it suited for Xfinity?

When it comes to bandwidth, the device performed really well with my Xfinity Gigabit plan. Testing it both near and far from my gaming studio, i.e., at 3 feet and 40 feet away, the speeds for the 5GHz band on a laptop clocked at 885 Mbps and 745 Mbps, respectively. On the other hand, at the 2.4GHz band, speed scores stayed at 227 Mbps and 122 Mbps.

Furthermore, OFDMA works towards eliminating the traffic and clearing out the path to deliver stronger signals.

WiFi Coverage & Connections Capacity

With 4 antennas stabbing out of the back panel, this Xfinity router delivers decent coverage and penetrates through most interferences to deliver a stable connection. The device should sheath any 1500-1800 Sq Ft space with reliable internet provided there aren’t many thick walls.

Besides, I can assure you of getting decent speeds in up to 10-12 devices at once, thanks to its 160MHz support and additional DFS channels.

Ports & Connectivity

4 Gigabit Ethernet ports are on its back panel for devices such as smart-TV, gaming consoles, mobile devices, or laptops that work better to deliver a lag-free wired connection. Besides, there’s USB 3.1 support that allows you to share data on your flash drive much faster.

Security Features

As mentioned in my RT-AX82U review, Security is a forte of this router as it includes a lifetime-free security suite called AiProtection to monitor any malicious or virus-ingrained websites.

So, your network and home devices don’t require an additional subscription, unlike other routers. Besides, its parental control feature gives you the power to handle your kids’ online activities.

Conclusion

Overall, RT-AX82U from ASUS is one of the top routers that work with Xfinity. Apart from gaming-exclusive features, its speeds and coverage are excellent for small-medium homes. Pair it with a gaming modem, and you’ll have a proper setup ready to experience low-latency gameplay.

3. Best Modem Router Combo: ARRIS Surfboard G34 Gateway

Arris Surfboard G34 is a versatile device that lets you relish the perks of a DOCSIS 3.1 modem and a Wi-Fi 6 router in it. It’s a great pick for anyone who wants something similar to the xFi gateway but with powerful connectivity, features, and control.

Why is it suited for Xfinity?

When paired with Xfinity’s Extreme Pro plan, I could witness a download speed of 754 Mbps while upload speeds stood at 26 Mbps. These are as good as you can get with a modem and wireless router as separate devices. (Learn the differences)

The built-in router is powerful enough to let you download UHD movies within seconds, play online games at 90fps and video conferencing or web browsing side by side without any lags or dropouts.

WiFi Coverage & Connections Capacity

When it comes to range, this Xfinity-compatible modem router combo is good enough to cover an area of 1800-2500 Sq Ft. So it’s safe to install this device in any mid-size apartment or office. And, its antennas are powerful enough to transmit strong signals on as many as 25 devices at a stretch, which is relatively high considering my family of nine.

Ports & Connectivity

Surfboard G34 boasts 4 GigE LAN ports that let you connect your bandwidth-hungry devices directly and gain a massive speed boost. However, it lacks a USB port and the LAN ports don’t support Link aggregation.

Security Features

Security features aren’t advanced in this device, so you might need to purchase a separate antivirus to protect your connected devices from malware. Besides, there’s support for an app that entails integrated parental controls to keep track of your kids’ online activities and pause the internet anytime.

Conclusion

Overall, Arris G34 is hands down the best modem router combo for Xfinity available in the market today. So, whatever your need for purchasing a router, you can have this versatile device to pair and get speeds fast enough to handle most of your bandwidth-hungry tasks.

Read my ARRIS G34 review for more detailed information.

4. Best Netgear Router for Xfinity: Nighthawk RAX43

Nighthawk RAX43 is a nice all-around Netgear router that combines a cool spaceship look with nice features that fulfil the needs of most families out there. Besides, its suitability with most high-speed internet, thanks to its upgraded features over RAX40, makes it a solid wireless router for Comcast Xfinity.

Why is it suited for Xfinity?

I was reasonably impressed with the speeds the device delivers with the Gigabit plan. The band-aggregated speed at 5 feet distance reached a maximum of 835 Mbps while keeping the device 50 feet away registered a speed of 550 Mbps.

On the other hand, speeds on its highest frequency band turned out to be around 860 Mbps and 590 Mbps at respective distances. This thrashes many known routers out of the park.

But, at this price range, some features like MU-MIMO and QoS support are missing. So, working at a fair distance away from the device or multiple uses might incur some instances of inconsistencies or instability.

WiFi Coverage & Connections Capacity

The 4 external antennas of this router come with beamforming support, so you are bound to get high-speed internet anywhere in your 2,500 Sq Ft room. I connected up to eight devices, each performing various tasks like gaming, 4K streaming, video conferencing, and others, and the network was still running smoothly.

Ports & Connectivity

Similar to my previous recommendation, you won’t find any multi-gig ports RAX43, which is quite justified provided with the price it’s offered. Besides, there are 4 Gigabit LANs and 1 Gigabit WAN port to which you can plug in your device directly to experience faster speeds.

Other than that, a USB 3.0 port is available to connect your non-networking devices like a flash drive, printers, scanners, and others for faster data transfer.

Security Features

Security-wise, RAX43 has a lot of great stuff to offer, but you might need to pay for the best bits. I’m talking about Netgear Armor and parental controls, which comes with a 1-year free trial. With these in place, you won’t have to worry about the safety of your device or your children, so I won’t mind paying, do you?

Conclusion

So, is Netgear Nighthawk worth pairing with Xfinity? I’d say definitely yes. It’s one of the best routers to use with Comcast Internet. It offers decent speeds, coverage, and performance. But the lack of crucial features like MU-MIMO, QoS, and no multi-gig support takes it in the third position.

5. Best Value for Money: TP-Link Archer AX55

TP-Link’s mid-range offering Archer AX55 is a perfect option for those looking for great power and features without having to break the bank. Anyone subscribed to decent speed plans and a medium-sized home is sure to get value with this router.

Besides, with respect to its preceding model, Archer AX50, it boasts an additional Qualcomm chip and much-improved performance.

Why is it suited for Xfinity?

At this price point, I am pretty impressed with the performance it delivers. Paired with the Blast service plan, the download speed in the 2.4GHz band clocked 454 Mbps, while the upload speed reached 12.2 Mbps. Note that these are considered good download and upload speeds.

In addition to that, the features like OFDMA, DFS, and Airtime Fairness eliminate network congestion and ensure strong signals are transmitted every time. These things were missing in my previous recommendation, which is why occasional throughput issues exist.

WiFi Coverage & Connections Capacity

The collapsible external antennas come with beamforming support to deliver signals in an area up to 3,000 Sq Ft. My friend has been using the router for the last three months and has no coverage issues anywhere in his 2,400 Sq Ft home. Plus, we played Warzone on six gaming consoles at once, not only because we were skilled but because that network was very much stable.

Ports & Connectivity

Like my previous recommendation, there isn’t any multi-Gig Ethernet port, but with 1 Gigabit WAN and 4 Gigabit LAN port, you can connect your devices to boost your internet speeds. Besides, there is a USB 3.0 port to which you can connect any external hardware you wish. As compared to USB 2.0, it offers faster charging and data speeds.

Security Features

Like most TP-Link routers, you need to pay monthly to get access to its commercial-grade security features, Homeshield Pro, powered by Bitdefender. However, I reckon its basic features like WPA3 and VPN-passthrough are more than suitable for most residential settings.

Besides, the advanced parental controls also come under the subscription, and you get features like pausing Wi-Fi and monitoring the active online time of your kids for free.

Conclusion

To conclude, this mid-tier TP-Link router is a reliable device with decent speeds and coverage. Some of its services need a subscription but are of great value for people who are into gaming, streaming videos, or working from home.

6. Best Mesh WiFi System for Xfinity: Amazon Eero 6+

The Eero 6+ does almost everything right, from features to value for people who want the most out of their high-speed connection, along with a reliable experience. With Wi-Fi 6 support and decent speed output, you can get decent speed on your phones or laptops even in a dense housing area.

And compared to other options on the list, Eero 6+ is an Xfinity-compatible WiFi mesh system. So you’ll get two nodes for consistent signals across your house.

Why is it suited for Xfinity?

Amazon Eero 6+ with Wi-Fi 6 support, you can pair it with Gigabit or mid-tier Blast plan. I tested it with the Gigabit plan, the mesh setup yields speeds up to 800 Mbps and 300 Mbps for 5GHz and 2.4GHz bands, respectively. While moving the system a fair away from the device reduced speeds by 30%, i.e. 560 Mbps and 210 Mbps.

WiFi Coverage & Connections Capacity

Eero 6+ boasts 4 internal antennas with beamforming support. Each unit covers an area of up to 1500 Sq Ft, so you can get seamless connectivity in a two-three story house spreading up to 3,000 Sq Ft. I could connect up to 35 devices at my friend’s office without disrupting the stability of the network.

Furthermore, the standalone feature of this mesh is its self-patented TrueMesh technology that intelligently routes the traffic to eliminate drop-offs and dead spots. So, you can experience truly super speeds almost every time.

Ports & Connectivity

Amazon hasn’t been very lenient in terms of ports. With two available ports, one is occupied by the modem, and you have only a single port to plug in your device directly. So, if you have multiple wired connections, you’re better off investing in WiFi mesh systems with multiple ethernet ports.

Besides, there’s only a single USB-C port that you can use to power the device with an external power supply, so there goes connecting not-networking devices down the drain.

Security Features

You’ll find some basic features like VPN-passthrough and WPA3, which is usable only when you have compatible devices. Besides, you can upgrade to its two-fold security: Eero Secure and Secure Plus for advanced options like ad blocking, threat detection and others like 1Password and Encrypt.me VPN.

Additionally, the subscription services provide you access to better parental controls. You can schedule your kids’ online time, block dangerous or age-inappropriate websites and pause your WiFi anytime.

Conclusion

Despite having a lower speed output than previous options, the Eero 6+ mesh is a dependable device that offers excellent value for money. This feature-rich dual-band router is an excellent choice for combining your high-speed Comcast Xfinity plans and easily performing most of your bandwidth-intensive tasks.

Do you want to learn more? Check out my full review of the Eero 6+ mesh.

7. Best Budget Option: ASUS RT-AC67P

Are you in search of the best budget router to buy for Xfinity? RT-AC67P from ASUS is my ideal pick. Read more to find out if it’s yours too!

ASUS RT-AC67P is a viable budget option that outperforms the older RT-AX56U in terms of speed, reliability, connection capacity and ports. So, let’s take a closer look!

Why is it suited for Xfinity?

The dual-band wireless router allows you to enjoy dependable and fast internet access on your home network. Suitable with any plan with speeds up to 600 Mbps, it’s a reliable device in any residential setting.

I paired the router with Xfinity Blast to get speeds up to 554 Mbps and 115 Mbps on my 5GHz and 2.4GHz bands, respectively. And thanks to MU-MIMO technology combined with its patented AiRadar beamforming technology, you get fine-tined wireless signals over extended distances.

WiFi Coverage & Connections Capacity

Coverage is the forte of this device as it combines its three high-performance antennas with other technologies to sheath a 3,000 Sq Ft area with a stable internet connection. It is on par with many high-end routers on my list. Plus, you can connect and work on up to 15 devices at once without experiencing any inconsistencies or lags.

Ports & Connectivity

With 4 GigE ports in place, you can connect most of your devices like gaming consoles, PC, laptops or others to get a speed boost compared to its wireless connectivity. Apart from that, a USB 3.1 Gen 1 Type-A connector allows you to transfer faster data to any of your non-networking devices like printers, flash drivers, scanners and others.

Security Features

Among other things, the security features offered by the mesh system are subpar. It supports WPA2 encryption, which is quite old but still does a good job of keeping your passcodes safe and secure. Furthermore, there are no parental controls, and the only thing you can do is pause the internet connection on a single device or multiple devices at the same time.

Conclusion

ASUS RT-AC67P is a suitable choice to replace Xfinity router and get rid of Comcast slow internet issue which you might face with the xFi gateway.

Its three beamforming antennas transmit stable signals, but the device substantially falls behind in terms of speed and security features from other devices on my list. It is why the device is ranked last in the list of good routers for Xfinity.

Frequently Asked Questions

Verdict

That’s all there is to say about the best wireless routers for Xfinity. I hope this article helps you make an informed decision. However, if you are still stuck, here are some personal suggestions:

• If you need top-notch features, tri-band Wi-Fi support and other technologies like MU-MIMO, and multi-gig support, then TP-Link Archer AX90 is your go-to option.
• If there’s a need for a reliable yet value-for-money router, I recommend choosing Netgear Nighthawk RAX43. Compatibility with mid-range internet plans, vast coverage and integration of advanced technologies are some of its alluring features.
• Lastly, ASUS RT-AC67P is an optimal option if you need a good budget-friendly option to replace the Xfinity router.

With that, I’d wrap this up. Let me know in the comments below which one you have gone for!